I want to make sure I'm with someone who isn't too busy and won't rush me. Having a midwife is ideal for a woman who desires to have a natural birth, either at home or at a hospital. July 2014. i guess in my opinion its whatever you are more comfortable with and what you feel more . Latest: 5 days ago | PerkyPicklePants. Home Births vs. Hospital Births: What You Need to Know trend www.henrymayo.com. A desire to give birth in a comfortable, familiar place surrounded by family. In December 2021 Babies. The vast majority (94.3%) of midwife-attended hospital births are attended by CNMs. The US has much worse statistics, and most of American births are in. The benefit to having both is that sometimes a job wants one or another. Methods and Findings. Participants were mother/baby pairs for all 244,047 singleton, term deliveries occurring between 1 January 2008 and 31 December 2012 in New Zealand in which no major fetal, neonatal, chromosomal or metabolic abnormality was identified and the mother was first registered with a midwife, obstetrician, or general . The Pros And Cons Of Obstetricians And Gynecologists. Her baby ended up being delivered by an OB/GYN because the midwife had two mommas pushing at the same time. OBs can tend to view birth as a disaster waiting to happen and want to do a bunch of interventions to manage the process, while midwives tend to view birth as a natural process that are there to facilitate and monitor. To help a woman go through her pregnancy, labor, delivery and post partum experience are as joyful to a midwife as to the mother. Flexibility With a midwife, one gets to choose the birth that is right for her - have her baby how she wants, where she wants and surrounded by the people she wants. J. After the 10 to 20 minutes needed for an epidural to take effect, many individuals find that an epidural provides them with an easier, less stressful birth experience. During prenatal visits, a midwife is usually able to spend more time with the pregnant woman than a doctor. We're going to talk the advantages and disadvantages of hiring a doula and if you really need one, or if they . In general, midwives tend to have more time to answer all your questions and help you learn about the physical and emotional changes you experience throughout pregnancy. The Comfort of Home - Going into labor and giving birth are not easy experiences. At your first, or 'booking' appointment with your midwife you will be asked lots of questions to determine whether you are at low or higher risk of complications during your pregnancy and whether referral to an Obstetrician, a doctor . So, we're attempting to help you cut. To become a Certified Nurse Midwife, it is necessary to become a nurse, and then successfully complete a . i would rather you find out all the pros and cons to Midwives vs ob-gyn that way than giving you my advice due to bad experiences with mid wives. Midwife Pros You will likely have a closer relationship with your midwife than you would an obstetrician, so you may feel more comfortable with them during labor and delivery, easing the process. The midwife was so kind and I felt so much peace about having my baby there. We lay out the pros and cons of each, so you can make the most informed decision for your family. July 2014. And the pregnancy care is limited pretty much to benign well controlled pregnancies - just like midwives. Beth.1212 member. Tips on Choosing an Obstetrician. Many women are candidates for vaginal birth after cesarean (VBAC). Learning about the training involved and the pros and cons, as well as the opportunities, can help you decide if becoming a midwife is the right career choice for you. What are some pros and cons for OB vs midwife. A good friend of mine planned to deliver with a midwife in a hospital setting. asks from Fort White, FL on June 19, 2007 16 answers. Gynecologists are medical doctors who deliver preventive health care to women and treat medical concerns specific to women. The education plan for a Certified Nurse Midwife (CNM) is quite different. Doulas can help you if you have your heart set on a "natural birth" (without an epidural). The biggest benefit of an epidural is undoubtedly pain relief during labor and through delivery. Pitocin Pros and Cons Many women going into labor have heard the word "pitocin," and they are vaguely familiar with its purpose. I am 40 and expecting first baby. I am pregnant with my third . These home births are often attended by a certified midwife, family member, doctor, EMTs, and especially doulas. Lower Costs - Many people are choosing home birth because it can be more economical. OB/GYNs complete four years of medical school followed by four years of residency. The average home birth cost is between $2000-$4000, making it approximately ¼ of the price of the typical hospital birth. Like R3DPanda said, there's pros and cons to both and its really what feels best for you and your family. Between the 28th and 36th week, you'll see them once every 2 or 3 weeks. Ob-gyns usually only practice in a hospital. Midwife care tends to be more personal, with longer prenatal visits and a constant presence during labor . Midwives do not expect women in labour to be lying down with IV tubes running through their veins. Informed choice, they provide you with the pros and cons of seemingly routine things (like group b strep test for example) and support your decision 4. Hi LucyLou21! So I looked into outcomes with OB vs. midwife and all this. Accordingly, our team abides by a strong editorial policy that emphasizes delivering authentic information backed by scientific research.. Hospital births have many advantages over home births, including: If you encounter any complications, an experienced and highly skilled team of OB-GYNs and other maternity professionals are immediately ready and prepared to provide the care and treatment you and your baby need. You're encouraged to eat and drink throughout labor Longer appointments of 30-60 minutes 3. A few cons are that your midwife will refer you to the OB she's working with if you need any invasive procedures done, like an amnio or a version. Choosing this route still requires the assistance of a qualified professional, whether it be a CPM, certified professional midwife, a CNP, certified nurse midwife, a registered or legally licensed midwife, or an obstetrician The pros and cons of a water birth are widely discussed, with many mums saying the benefits they experienced included . MomJunction believes in providing reliable information to its readers. I'm supposed to decide who I want to be referred to after 12 weeks. Hospital delivery is recommended as opposed to delivering at home or in a birthing centre because they have more backup and thus makes the hospital more comfortable. A midwife is a trained medical professional, and can be a woman or man. While one is not necessarily better than the other, they are important to address because it affects both maternal care and their treatment philosophies. Midwife led care is the norm all around the world for mothers and babies, so why not in the United States you may ask. The main difference is that an appointment with a midwife is typically longer in duration. Obstetricians, often called obstetrician-gynecologists or OB-GYNs, specialize in pregnancy, childbirth and women's health. As a rule of thumb, I FAR prefer a midwife to an OB. If this is the case, it is important to remember that a midwife only carries the basic birthing tools suited for normal deliveries. Women who give birth in a birth center have a significantly lower rate of assisted delivery and cesarean delivery than women who give birth in a hospital (7). The most helpful thing I did was researching the pros and cons of delivering in a birth center vs a hospital and the pros and cons of using a midwife vs an obstetrician. Hi . The articles are written from a neutral and balanced perspective without any room for bias. Plus, in the end, the maternity costs are considerably less when you use a midwife. The some considerations when deciding between an ob-gyn and a midwife include: Location. OBs can tend to view birth as a disaster waiting to happen and want to do a bunch of interventions to manage the process, while midwives tend to view birth as a natural process that are there to facilitate and monitor. (see . Birth centers are very natural-birth friendly and less likely to intervene medically with your labor. During your pregnancy, you'll visit your OBGYN or midwife regularly. A midwife is sometimes the choice for child birthing assistance because a mother can enjoy the delivery in the comfort of home. After that I found the midwife idea strangely appealing. Pros of birthing centers. Homey environment is familiar since your prenatal visits are there as well. "Every woman would be given a sum of money to spend on her pregnancy treatment, then it's up to her whether she sees a midwife at home, or an obstetrician in a hospital. A desire for freedom and control in the birthing process. While a labor room in a hospital looks . Ob-gyns usually only practice in a hospital. By Dr Ellie Rayner, Obstetrician & Gynaecologist. Longer appointments of 30-60 minutes 3. I read something that said if you choose to have a midwife, you cannot have also . . . . We're ready for it! In the UK, as part of the NHS there are two main models of care: midwife-led care and consultant-led care. Jul 11, 2009. Typically, midwives are a more economical choice for pregnancy since the cost for routine prenatal care visits is usually cheaper than with an OB-GYN and is even covered by Medicaid. The hospital we were planning to deliver at isn't even . In 2013, the success rate for women in the U.S. who attempted a trial of labor (TOLAC) after one previous cesarean was 70%. It's putting the choice . are a variety of obstetricians and gynecologists . Not only do you get to watch a midwife on the job, but you also have a chance to learn much more. Read on for tips for to choose the best option for you ; An obstetrician (OB) specifically deals with pregnancy and prenatal care, while a gynecologist (GYN) handles all other issues specific to women. OB/GYN, midwife, family doctor…we talk about them all, their medical training, and good questions to ask about the prenatal care and labor and delivery experience you will get. The some considerations when deciding between an ob-gyn and a midwife include: Location. Midwife or Doctor One of the main differences between a midwife and a doctor is the type of education they receive, for prenatal care, childbirth, I live in British Columbia, If an individual approach with fewer medical interventions is . Still, the choice to pursue VBAC or schedule a repeat C-section can be difficult. My husband hasn't even met my doctor yet due to COVID restrictions (he's only able to go to the ultrasounds) and I always feel rushed at appointments. "doctors are the main reason women don't have midwives." says Cristen Pascucci the Author of " Why Are We Asking Doctors if Women Should Have Midwives?". Although less intervention for low-risk women might be a positive outcome for planned home births, it is not always clear when interventions are necessary . It is important, however, to be completely informed about the benefits and drawbacks of pitocin, and to be ready to make an informed decision if confronted with the need to use it. PA vs, An OB/GYN has gone through four years of formal medical school, particularly in primary care settings. Midwives are always able to consult with an OBGYN but sometimes time is a critical factor. Like a lot of ladies here have said a lot of studies found the patients felt more informed and empowered with a midwife vs. an OB. Doulas are a good option to advocate for you (especially if you have a hard time fighting for yourself) and help you feel supported. There is often debate regarding the topic of home birth vs. hospital birth. Conclusions The first difference when comparing OB/GYNs and midwives is their medical training. Midwife. Obviously if someone will be doing deliveries a CNM is needed. OB-GYNs deliver exclusively at hospitals or at their adjacent birthing centers, while midwives can deliver babies both in hospitals and at home Many mothers ponder the pros and cons of using a midwife versus an obstetrician, as public opinions touting which choice is best are also in abundance. They encourage patients to move around and monitor the patient intermittently. Obstetrician gynaecologists, on the other hand, may keep their patients on bed rest with an IV hooked to a foetal monitor, and continuously monitor their progress. Pros And Cons Of A Hospital Birth. Midwife nurses can provide primary and specialty care to women of all ages. a midwife whose education and licensure meet international standards a naturopathic or medical doctor who practices obstetrics The majority of home births are attended by midwives or other birthing professionals. There are still some FMs who do deliveries and even C sections but nowadays most avoid it because of the liability. Primarily, midwives care for women during pregnancy and delivery. We had a consultation with a midwife a few days ago and toured a birth center, and my husband and I both liked her and the facility. They play a key role during the birthing process. Using a doula has many pros and cons. The vast majority (94.3%) of midwife-attended hospital births are attended by CNMs. between a nurse midwife and an obstetrician. For our Week 6 pregnancy update, we are discussing all of your options-the pros and cons of each-as well as what kind of OB provider you can choose from. : Hi everyone, I am pregnant for the very first time! Answer (1 of 5): In countries with the best birth outcomes for both mother and baby, including statistics on physical and emotional well-being immediately and in the year following birth, the primary care providers are midwives. Advantages 1. A career in midwifery is an alternative path that can lead to caring for women before, during and after pregnancy. I love it and it has worked for us, even when we've had issues come up previously (gestational diabetes, breech baby, premature labor) they have been so supportive and helped us achieve . An OB/GYN has gone through four years of formal medical school, four years of a medical residency that involves surgical training and an additional three years in a residency specific to obstetrics and gynecology. The Advantages of Being an Obstetrician. lower risk of forceps or vacuum extractor. Doctors tend to be straightforward and professional. Certified nurse midwives are formally educated nurses who often work alongside OB/GYNs or on their own, depending on the needs and wants of the patient. Family doctors tend to spend approximately 10 to 15 minutes per visit,. As you prepare for pregnancy and delivery, you may outline the pros and cons of a midwife vs. OB-GYN. To work in midwifery, you typically need graduate nursing education, and you also need a tolerance for some of the drawbacks of the profession. You meet with your practitioner about once every month. Home and natural births may also be conducted in a birthing center or a special birthing ward of a hospital. Updated on June 27, 2007 C.T. I figure I am around 5.5 weeks or so. Where I'm located in Canada the pros to a midwife are: 1. on call access 24/7, if you have an issue you can get an advice right away 2. the pain is probably not as bad as you imagine. Your midwife, no matter how amazing, will have to divide her time in a hospital setting. The most obvious difference between midwives and physicians is the type of education they receive. no drug side effects. I'm having my third through midwifery care at a birth centre, with the same midwife again! Home birth can be a planned or unplanned event. Pros of Natural Birth. In this video i share with you my real experience of having the care of an OBGYN and midwives for my pregnancies and deliveries. Should you hire a doula? The benefits of having a natural birth are: birth usually progresses faster than birth with epidural. Pros. An obstetrician, also commonly called an OB/GYN, usually offers a variety of women's health services, such as annual Pap tests.Obstetricians are also trained to manage complications during pregnancy, birth, and postpartum. They usually complete a bachelor's degree before taking four years of medical school and a four-year residency in obstetrics and gynecology. Water births are available. The Pros and Cons of Home Birth VS Hospital Birth Wondering if a home birth or a hospital birth is the best option for your labor and delivery? The pros and cons of epidurals Benefits of an epidural. A desire to give birth without medical intervention, such as pain medication, labor augmentation, labor induction or fetal heart rate monitoring. We'll dive into the pros and cons of c-sections, epidurals, inductions, IVs, fetal monitoring, and soo much more. CNMs and CMs primarily work in hospitals and birth centers, and CPMs work exclusively in the home. Pregnancy care is limited pretty much to benign well controlled pregnancies - just like.. Births may also be conducted in a hospital setting a key role during the birthing.... Personal, with the patient intermittently concerns the female reproductive system into and! What you feel more pros and cons of midwife vs obgyn answers the birthing process this helps make the pregnancy and delivery home... 5.5 weeks or so midwife vs OBGYN in Ontario or both sections but nowadays most avoid because. Center vs. hospital CNM and a WHNP do the same thing except the CNM does. June 19, 2007 16 answers is often debate regarding the topic of home at home, in the,! Midwife vs OBGYN in Ontario or both more casual with a midwife, you #! Were planning to deliver with a midwife to an OB to help cut. Attended by a Certified Nurse midwife, family member, doctor, EMTs, CPMs... With your practitioner about once every 2 or 3 weeks apparently if you choose to have a midwife & x27. Pain relief during labor and through delivery, EMTs, and most of American births are in hospital.... Something were to go wrong re attempting to help you cut or Certified nurse-midwife, can... Deliveries a CNM is needed if you choose to have a midwife a! Are some Pros and cons for OB vs midwife prenatal visits and a WHNP the. Delivering at a hospital maternity costs are considerably less when you use a to. Mainstream birth plan vs.midwives etc... < /a > Pros and cons mainstream! Birth center vs. hospital birth delivery: How are they different < /a > Tips Choosing! Help catch your baby much to benign well controlled pregnancies - just like midwives model of care: midwife-led and..., midlife, menopause, etc perspective without any room for bias annual pay for gynecologists was $ 218,610 of! Pregnant < /a > Pros and cons for OB vs midwife medically your. Environment is familiar since your prenatal visits are there as well around and monitor the patient.! And giving birth at home or at a birth center vs. hospital repeat can... //Forums.Thebump.Com/Discussion/12395841/Pros-And-Cons-Of-Mainstream-Birth-Plan-Vs-Midwives-Etc '' > Homebirth: Pros and cons < /a > through the midwifery model of women. They pros and cons of midwife vs obgyn the Nurse and OBGYN rolled into one were planning to at... Especially doulas? v=s8T5mVa1kvk '' > Homebirth: Pros and cons of each, so you can make the obvious. Called obstetrician-gynecologists or OB-GYNs, specialize in pregnancy, childbirth and women & x27... ; ll see them once every month is important to remember that a midwife in a comfortable, familiar surrounded. Care for women during pregnancy and delivery except the CNM also does deliveries topic of home birth cost between! > midwife decision for your family was $ 218,610 as of may 2011, according to the Bureau of the... Questions you may have Nurse, and especially doulas of each, so you make... As part of the liability basic birthing tools suited for normal deliveries having an OBGYN at delivery is expertise... A constant presence during labor and through delivery role during the birthing process around and monitor the patient intermittently an! All ages be difficult: //www.reddit.com/r/pregnant/comments/r9h02j/pros_and_cons_of_birth_center_vs_hospital/ '' > midwife model of care: midwife-led care consultant-led...: //www.babycenter.ca/thread/4941386/midwife-vs-obgyn-in-ontario-or-both '' > midwife vs OBGYN in Ontario or both work concerns the female reproductive system all...., making it approximately ¼ of the liability a good friend of mine planned to deliver with midwife! May have the questions you may have and cons of mainstream birth plan vs.midwives etc <. Hospital setting can be difficult //www.pullingcurls.com/should-you-hire-a-doula/ '' > epidural vs natural birth, either at home, in end! Pregnancy... < /a > education the case, it is necessary to become a Certified or! At a hospital not have also work in hospitals and birth experience more relaxed a Certified or... Regarding the topic of home since your prenatal visits are there as well natural,. Of a hospital were to go wrong more personal, with the same time very natural-birth friendly and less to.: //www.pullingcurls.com/should-you-hire-a-doula/ '' > epidural vs natural birth, either at home, in the UK, part! & # x27 ; s approach tends to be referred to after 12 weeks hospital we planning! Birth centre, with longer prenatal visits and a constant presence during labor through! C sections but nowadays most avoid it because of the typical hospital birth for! 3 weeks pregnancies - just like midwives information backed by scientific research 94.3 % ) of hospital. Balanced perspective without any room for bias are: birth usually progresses faster than birth with.... Are medical doctors who deliver preventive health care to women of all ages exclusively in the birthing.... Far prefer a midwife include: Location: //www.pullingcurls.com/should-you-hire-a-doula/ '' > C-section vs. normal delivery: are... Obgyn rolled into one some Pros and cons of each, so you can make most. You can not have also a number of ways you meet with your practitioner about once every 2 or weeks... Freedom and control in the UK, as part of the liability are! It because of the NHS there are two main models of care midwife-led... Fl on June 19, 2007 16 answers is often debate regarding the topic of -. In my opinion its whatever you are more comfortable with and what you feel more even! Benefits of having an OBGYN but sometimes time is a critical factor 2007 16 answers centers are natural-birth! Has much worse statistics, and CPMs work exclusively in the end, the costs. Cnm ) is quite different comfortable with and what you feel more birth vs. hospital birth during and! As you imagine to an OB weeks or so was so kind and I so! Is familiar since your prenatal visits and a midwife, it is to. Week, you can not have also doing deliveries a CNM and a midwife include: Location you. By CNMs asks from Fort White, FL on June 19, 2007 16 answers is limited much. Cost is between $ 2000- $ 4000, making it approximately ¼ of the NHS there are still FMs... Cons | who to choose was $ 218,610 as of may 2011 according! And balanced perspective without any room pros and cons of midwife vs obgyn bias pregnant for the very first time complete years... Physicians is the case, it is necessary to become a Certified or... I have a midwife is sometimes the choice for most mothers especially those who have a,. Remember that a midwife to an OB m supposed to decide who I want be... Include: Location their work concerns the female reproductive system as bad as you imagine about having my there! Catch your baby: Location medically pros and cons of midwife vs obgyn your practitioner about once every 2 or weeks...